Free Shipping on Order over $150+ Call 1-608-846-4455

Collection: Cheddar - 6 Weeks to 20 Years Old!!

We age all of our cheddar in our special cheese aging coolers. We have over 40,000 lbs. of aging cheddar at all times. Choose from mild cheddar (aged only a few weeks) all the way up to 20 year old Plaid! The older cheddar gets, the dryer and "sharper" it gets.

13 products
  • 5 Year Old Double Sharp Cheddar
    5 Year Aged Double Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $9.25
    Sale price
    $9.25
  • 10 Year Old Uber Sharp Cheddar
    10 Years Aged Uber Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $15.75
    Sale price
    $15.75
  • 1 Year Sharp Cheddar
    1 Years Aged Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $6.25
    Sale price
    $6.25
  • 4 Year Old Udderly Sharp WHITE Cheddar
    4 Years Aged Udderly Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $8.25
    Sale price
    $8.25
  • 2 Year Old Extra Sharp Cheddar
    2 Years Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $6.75
    Sale price
    $6.75
  • 3 Year Old Super Sharp Cheddar
    3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $7.25
    Sale price
    $7.25
  • 7 Year Old Mega Sharp Cheddar
    7 Years Aged Mega Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $11.75
    Sale price
    $11.75
  • 6-12 Month Old Medium Cheddar
    6-12 Months Aged Medium Cheddar
    Regular price
    $6.99
    Sale price
    $5.75
  • 15 Year Old Ludicrous Sharp Cheddar
    15 Years Aged Ludicrous Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $25.75
    Sale price
    $25.75
  • 4-6 Week Old Mild Cheddar
    Mild 4-6 Weeks Aged Cheddar
    Regular price
    $6.75
    Sale price
    $5.25
  • 12 Year Hyper Sharp Cheddar
    12 Years Aged Hyper Sharp Cheddar
    Regular price
    $18.25
    Sale price
    $18.25
  • 23 Year Plaid Aged Cheddar - 8 ounces
    20 Year Cheddar Blocks
    Regular price
    $100.00
    Sale price
    $100.00