Collections
-
5 Items
Award Winning Cheeses
Award Winning Cheeses
Winning cheeses from the 2025 United States Championship Cheese Contest!
-
8 Items
Baked Cheeses
Baked Cheeses
These far-out cheeses are totally baked, man! The baking process gives this buttery cheese a firm and tasty crust. B...
-
5 Items
BellaVitano
BellaVitano
This Sartori Cheese is similar to parmesan with a slightly creamier texture and variety of flavors.
-
56 Items
Berres Brothers Coffee
Berres Brothers Coffee
A Wisconsin Coffee Roaster Bringingyou a Daily Escape from the Ordinary At Berres Brothers, our vision is simple: t...
-
2 Items
Blue Cheese
Blue Cheese
The blue cheese family has different types of mold that are used to make the cheese more sour or even sometimes more ...
-
9 Items
Brick Cheese
Brick Cheese
We have enough bricks to build a house! This medium-soft cheese family is native to Wisconsin. If you’re looking for...
-
Candy
Candy
Discover our curated selection of candy products.
-
13 Items
Cheddar - 6 Weeks to 20 Years Old!!
Cheddar - 6 Weeks to 20 Years Old!!
We age all of our cheddar in our special cheese aging coolers. We have over 40,000 lbs. of aging cheddar at all times...
-
17 Items
Cheddars with a Twist!
Cheddars with a Twist!
Your favorite cheese with an added twist! Perfect to cook with or eat with crackers; our cheddars are carefully flav...
-
21 Items
Cheddars with a Twist!
Cheddars with a Twist!
Your favorite cheese with an added twist! Perfect to cook with or eat with crackers; our cheddars are carefully flav...
-
129 Items
Cheeses
Cheeses
Our wide selection of cheese is sure to impress! From something as simple as a Mild Cheddar to the explosive heat of ...
-
5 Items
Colby
Colby
Colby is a semi-hard, mild cheese that pairs nicely with a wide variety of adult beverages. Colby’s color and texture...
-
3 Items
Curd and String
Curd and String
A Wisconsin favorite, cheese curds are one of the mildest cheeses, and taste best when eaten at room temperature. We ...
-
12 Items
Fudge
Fudge
Delicious, homemade fudge is on the menu! Sold in half-pound (8 ounce) pieces, our fudge is a must-have for those wi...
-
49 Items
Gift Dept.
Gift Dept.
Choose from our selection of cheese utensils and fun gifts to add onto your cheese purchase!
-
6 Items
Gouda
Gouda
Our Gouda is good, eh? This buttery cheese is nutty and sweet but will become sharper as it ages while still retainin...
-
3 Items
Havarti
Havarti
As a member of the brick family; Havarti is buttery in aroma and texture. Below are some ages and flavors that we of...
-
2 Items
Honey Products
Honey Products
Discover our curated selection of honey products products.
-
12 Items
Italian
Italian
Mamma Mia! That’s a lotta mozza! Our Italian cheeses range from medium-soft, Mozzarella and Provolone - to hard, Par...
-
19 Items
Jams & Jellies
Jams & Jellies
Discover our curated selection of jams & jellies products.
-
1 Item
Jelly Belly
Jelly Belly
Discover our curated selection of jelly belly products.
-
9 Items
Maple Syrup
Maple Syrup
Discover our curated selection of maple syrup products.
-
7 Items
Monterey Jack
Monterey Jack
Similar in taste to Colby Cheese, this semi-hard family is mild and is offered in an assortment of flavors.
-
2 Items
Mousehouse Jack (Exclusive!)
Mousehouse Jack (Exclusive!)
Mousehouse Jack is our own recipe and most popular variety of cheese! Developed by Art Sobczak and Master Cheese-make...
-
2 Items
Nikki's "Sidewalk" Sale
Nikki's "Sidewalk" Sale
Discover our curated selection of nikki's "sidewalk" sale products.
-
11 Items
Pepper Cheese
Pepper Cheese
We have an assortment of Monterrey Jacks and Cheddar with a spicy twist! The twist is peppers! Choose the cheese tha...
-
6 Items
Processed American Cheese
Processed American Cheese
These unique and flavorful cheeses are produced when the cheese-maker heats it to about 150 degrees, which melts the...
-
37 Items
Sausage
Sausage
Our delicious selection of sausage ranges from snack sticks to summer sausage and come in a variety of meats, includi...
-
9 Items
Smoked Cheese
Smoked Cheese
Smoked locally in Evansville, WI, our smoked cheeses bring the perfect balance of hickory deliciousness to your dish!
-
20 Items
Soup & Baking Mixes
Soup & Baking Mixes
Discover our curated selection of soup & baking mixes products.
-
23 Items
Specialty Food Products
Specialty Food Products
Discover our curated selection of specialty food products products.
-
21 Items
Spreads
Spreads
Whether it be on crackers, on a sandwich, or as part of a recipe; our wide variety of cheese spreads are a fan-favori...
-
7 Items
Swiss
Swiss
The “hole”iest cheese! This mild and creamy cheese-family has subtle, nutty undertones that pair beautifully with a b...
-
14 Items
Taffy
Taffy
Discover our curated selection of taffy products.
-
4 Items
TNT Candied Pecans
TNT Candied Pecans
Discover our curated selection of tnt candied pecans products.
-
10 Items
Wisconsin Cheese Boxes
Wisconsin Cheese Boxes
Gourmet Gift Baskets for any occasion Free Shipping on all Gift Boxes per address Award winning Wisconsin Cheese make...
