Order Ahead for In-Store Pickup! Place Order Online or Call 1-608-846-4455!

Collection: Products

Pine River Pimento Cheese Spread 7oz

Regular price

$7.49

Sale price

$7.49
Pine River Spicy Beer Cheddar Spread, 7 oz

Regular price

$7.49

Sale price

$7.49
Pine River Spicy Pimento Cheese Spread 7oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Pineapple Pepper Jelly 18oz

Regular price

$10.99

Sale price

$10.99

Sold Out
Platinum Membership

Regular price

$500.00

Sale price

$500.00
Port Wine Cheddar Spread, 12 oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Provolone

Regular price

$5.99

Sale price

$5.99
Pure Country Sorghum

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49

Sold Out
Rabbit Creek Sheet Pan Pastry Kit

Regular price

$10.99

Sale price

$10.99
Rabbit Creek Shortcake Mix

Regular price

$10.99

Sale price

$10.99
Raspberry Chipotle Pepper Cheddar

Regular price

$6.25

Sale price

$6.25
Rhubarb-Raspberry Jam

Regular price

$10.99

Sale price

$10.99
Romano - Approx wt. 7 Ounces

Regular price

$14.25

Sale price

$14.25
Salsa

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Salted Caramel Brownie Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$14.49

Sale price

$14.49

Sold Out
Sartori Italian Herb Cheddar Cheese Bites

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49
Sartori Montamore Cheddar Cheese Bites

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49

Sold Out
Scorpion Pepper Cheddar

Regular price

$17.49

Sale price

$17.49
Scorpion Pepper Hot Sauce

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49

Sold Out
Sea Salt Caramel Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99
Seasoning

Regular price

$8.99

Sale price

$8.99
Seedless Black Raspberry Preserves 10.5oz

Regular price

$11.99

Sale price

$11.99

Sold Out
Sharp Cheddar Spread, 12oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Silver Creek Turkey Summer Sausage, 14oz

Regular price

$20.49

Sale price

$20.49

Sold Out
Silver Membership

Regular price

$100.00

Sale price

$100.00
Silver Spring Deli-Style Mustard

Regular price

$4.49

Sale price

$4.49
Silver Spring Dijon Mustard

Regular price

$4.49

Sale price

$4.49
Silver Spring Wasabi Sauce

Regular price

$4.49

Sale price

$4.49
Single Serve 24 ct. Berres Favorites Bundle

Regular price

$23.95

Sale price

$23.95

Sold Out
Single Serve 24 ct. Caramel Lovers Bundle

Regular price

$23.95

Sale price

$23.95

Sold Out
Single Serve 24 ct. Custom Blends and Roasts Bundle

Regular price

$23.95

Sale price

$23.95

Sold Out
Single Serve 24 ct. Flavor Factory Bundle

Regular price

$23.95

Sale price

$23.95

Sold Out
Single Serve 24 ct. Tasty Treats Bundle

Regular price

$23.95

Sale price

$23.95
Single Serve 48 ct. Everyday Variety Box

Regular price

$46.95

Sale price

$46.95
Skinny Sticks Cinnamon Spiced Maple Sugar

Regular price

$13.49

Sale price

$13.49

Sold Out
Skinny Sticks Pure Maple Cream

Regular price

$17.49

Sale price

$17.49

Sold Out
Slack's Fruit Butters

Regular price

$10.99

Sale price

$10.99

Sold Out
Slack's Jams/Jellies

Regular price

$8.49

Sale price

$8.49

Sold Out
Smoke and Fire Burger Starter

Regular price

$10.49

Sale price

$10.49
Smoked Baby Swiss

Regular price

$17.99

Sale price

$17.99
Smoked Bacon Colby

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49
Smoked Bacon Gouda, Approx wt. 12oz

Regular price

$16.61

Sale price

$16.61

Sold Out
Smoked Cheddar

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.25
Smoked Gouda, Approx wt. 12oz

Regular price

$12.49

Sale price

$12.49

Sold Out
Smoked Grand Cru - Gruyere

Regular price

$20.75

Sale price

$20.75
Smoked Habanero Pepper Jack

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49
Smoked Igor's Heat Pepper Jack

Regular price

$14.49

Sale price

$14.49
Smoked Mousehouse Jack

Regular price

$13.99

Sale price

$13.99
Smoked Provolone

Regular price

$6.99

Sale price

$6.99
Smokey Bacon Cheddar Spread, 12 oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Smokey Cheddar Spread, 12 oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Smokey Rib Sauce

Regular price

$10.49

Sale price

$10.49
Smoky Maple Glaze

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99

Sold Out
Smooth Operator Coffee

Regular price

$14.49

Sale price

$14.49
Southern Pecan Cream Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99
Southern Sweet Tea Jelly 18oz

Regular price

$10.99

Sale price

$10.99

Sold Out
Spicy Sweet Dill Pickles

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99

Sold Out
Stainless Steel Cheese Grater

Regular price

$9.99

Sale price

$9.99
Strawberry Preserve 10.5oz

Regular price

$7.49

Sale price

$7.49
Strawberry Preserve 5oz

Regular price

$5.49

Sale price

$5.49

Sold Out

Previous page
Page 6 of 7
Next page

Order Ahead for In-Store Pickup!

Place Order Online or Call 1-608-846-4455