Order Ahead for In-Store Pickup! Place Order Online or Call 1-608-846-4455!

Collection: Products

Cheese and Onion

Regular price

$4.49

Sale price

$4.49
Cheese and Salami

Regular price

$4.49

Sale price

$4.49
Cheese Crate 31

Regular price

$62.00

Sale price

$62.00
Cheese Crate 412

Regular price

$77.00

Sale price

$77.00
Cheese Curd Batter

Regular price

$8.99

Sale price

$8.99

Sold Out
Cheese Plane

Regular price

$9.99

Sale price

$9.99
Chicken Soup Monterey Jack,

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49

Sold Out
Chipotle Hot Sauce

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49

Sold Out
Chocolate Caramel Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$14.49

Sale price

$14.49
Chocolate Cheese with Walnuts

Regular price

$10.75

Sale price

$10.75
Chocolate Cherry Bomb Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$13.49

Sale price

$13.49

Sold Out
Chocolate Chip Cookie Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99
Chocolate Fudge (1/2 Pound)

Regular price

$9.50

Sale price

$9.50
Chocolate Raspberry Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99
Chocolate Walnut Fudge (1/2 Pound)

Regular price

$9.50

Sale price

$9.50
CinnaMan Grogg Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99
Coconut Chocolate Cocktail Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$13.49

Sale price

$13.49

Sold Out
Coffee Syrup

Regular price

$0.00

Sale price

$0.00
Colby Jack

Regular price

$5.75

Sale price

$5.75
Colby Jack Longhorn, Approx wt. 12oz

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49
Colby Longhorn, Approx wt. 12oz

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49
Colby Swiss, Approx wt. 12oz

Regular price

$10.49

Sale price

$10.49
Cookies & Cream Fudge (1/2 Pound)

Regular price

$9.50

Sale price

$9.50
Cow Utter Mug

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49
Cowboy Cheddar

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Cracked Black Pepper Gouda, Approx wt. 12oz

Regular price

$15.11

Sale price

$15.11

Sold Out
Cranberry Cheddar

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Cranberry Orange Cheddar

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49

Sold Out
Cranberry Preserve

Regular price

$8.49

Sale price

$8.49
Cream Cheese

Regular price

$3.49

Sale price

$3.49

Sold Out
Damson Plum Jam 18oz

Regular price

$10.99

Sale price

$10.99

Sold Out
Dark Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt Fudge (1/2 Pound)

Regular price

$9.50

Sale price

$9.50
Dark Sumatra Stout Coffee

Regular price

$14.55

Sale price

$14.55
DeFindsor, WI x Igor Mug

Regular price

$13.49

Sale price

$13.49
Dill Havarti

Regular price

$20.99

Sale price

$20.99
Dill Mustard

Regular price

$5.29

Sale price

$5.29
Door County Cherry Cheddar

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
English Toffee Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$64.00

Sale price

$60.00
Farmers Cheese

Regular price

$10.49

Sale price

$10.49
Fig Preserve 10.5oz

Regular price

$7.49

Sale price

$7.49

Sold Out
Fig Preserve 5oz

Regular price

$5.49

Sale price

$5.49

Sold Out
Foam Cheese Head

Regular price

$24.49

Sale price

$24.49
Freeze Dried Curd 1.9oz

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49
French Caramel Cream Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99
French Onion Soup Cheddar

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Fresh Tomato Salsa

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49

Sold Out
Garden Veggie Monterey Jack

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Garlic & Dill Cheddar

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Garlic & Herb Cheddar

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Garlic & Herb Cheddar Spread, 12 oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Garlic Pesto Monterey Jack

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Ghost Chili Pepper Jack

Regular price

$13.49

Sale price

$13.49
Gift Box 312

Regular price

$40.00

Sale price

$40.00
Gift Card

Regular price

$10.00

Sale price

$10.00
Gift for Good

Regular price

$0.01

Sale price

$0.01
Gold Membership

Regular price

$200.00

Sale price

$200.00
Good & Evil Pickles

Regular price

$13.99

Sale price

$13.99
Good and Evil Hot Sauce

Regular price

$5.99

Sale price

$5.99
Grand Cru - Gruyere

Regular price

$16.99

Sale price

$16.99
Green & Black Olive Cheddar

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49

Previous page
Page 3 of 7
Next page

Order Ahead for In-Store Pickup!

Place Order Online or Call 1-608-846-4455