Order Ahead for In-Store Pickup! Place Order Online or Call 1-608-846-4455!

Collection: Products

Green Chile Pepper Jack

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$8.25
Groovy Floral Mug

Regular price

$25.49

Sale price

$25.49
Habanero Honey Mustard

Regular price

$7.49

Sale price

$7.49

Sold Out
Habanero Pepper Jack

Regular price

$6.75

Sale price

$6.75
Hatch Pepper Cheddar

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49
Havarti

Regular price

$10.49

Sale price

$10.49
Highlander Grogg Cold Brew 6 oz Can

Regular price

$17.95

Sale price

$17.95

Sold Out
Highlander Grogg Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99
Highlander Grogg Whole Bean 12 oz Can

Regular price

$18.95

Sale price

$18.95
Horseradish & Chive Havarti

Regular price

$10.75

Sale price

$10.75
Horseradish Cheddar

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49
Horseradish Cheddar Spread, 12 oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Horseradish Monterey Jack

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49
Horseradish Mustard

Regular price

$7.49

Sale price

$7.49

Sold Out
Horseradish Sauce

Regular price

$5.29

Sale price

$5.29
Hot Buffalo Cheddar

Regular price

$14.99

Sale price

$14.99
Hot Horseradish Mustard

Regular price

$5.29

Sale price

$5.29
Hot Pepper Raspberry Preserve 10.5oz

Regular price

$8.99

Sale price

$8.99

Sold Out
I Put Makeup On For This? Mug 14 oz

Regular price

$25.49

Sale price

$25.49
Irish Cream Flavored Coffee

Regular price

$12.99

Sale price

$12.99

Sold Out
Jalapeno Cheddar Spread, 12 oz

Regular price

$7.99

Sale price

$7.99
Jalapeno Hot Sauce

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49

Sold Out
Jalapeno Pepper Jack

Regular price

$13.49

Sale price

$13.49
Jalapeno Pepper Jelly 5oz

Regular price

$5.49

Sale price

$5.49

Sold Out
Jelly Belly 3.5oz

Regular price

$4.49

Sale price

$4.49
Jims Blue Ribbon Summer Sausage, 14 oz

Regular price

$18.99

Sale price

$18.99
Jumbo Beef Sticks 7oz

Regular price

$8.99

Sale price

$8.99
Juusto Baked Cheese, 6 oz

Regular price

$11.49

Sale price

$11.49
Juusto filled with 5 year Cheddar, 6 oz

Regular price

$11.49

Sale price

$11.49
Juusto Italiano, 6 oz

Regular price

$11.49

Sale price

$11.49
Juusto with Bacon Crumbles, 6 oz

Regular price

$11.49

Sale price

$11.49
Juusto with Garlic, 6 oz

Regular price

$11.49

Sale price

$11.49
Juusto with Jalapeno Peppers, 6 oz

Regular price

$11.49

Sale price

$11.49
Juusto with Parmesan, 6 oz

Regular price

$11.49

Sale price

$11.49
Key Lime Jelly 10.5oz

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49

Sold Out
Key Lime Margarita Hot Sauce

Regular price

$5.99

Sale price

$5.99
LaClare Blueberry Vanilla Goat Cheese

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49
LaClare Chipotle Honey Goat Cheese

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49
LaClare Cranberry Cinnamon Goat Cheese

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49

Sold Out
LaClare Garlic & Herb Goat Cheese

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49
LaClare Goat Cheese Mozzarella

Regular price

$9.99

Sale price

$9.99
LaClare Goat Cheese Pepper Jack

Regular price

$9.99

Sale price

$9.99
LaClare Honey Goat Cheese

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49
LaClare Original Goat Cheese

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49
Lakeside's Dusseldorf German Mustard

Regular price

$4.79

Sale price

$4.79
Lakeside's Gourmet Honey Mustard

Regular price

$5.29

Sale price

$5.29

Sold Out
Lakeside's Jalapeño Mustard

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49
Limburger, 7 oz

Regular price

$8.75

Sale price

$8.75
Mad Mango Salsa

Regular price

$8.49

Sale price

$8.49
Mango Butter

Regular price

$8.49

Sale price

$8.49
Mango Fire Pepper Cheddar

Regular price

$17.49

Sale price

$17.49
Mango Garlic Hot Sauce

Regular price

$6.49

Sale price

$6.49

Sold Out
Mango Lime Salsa

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49

Sold Out
Maple Bacon Jam 18oz

Regular price

$8.99

Sale price

$8.99

Sold Out
Maple Syrup Cheddar

Regular price

$15.49

Sale price

$15.49
Marieke Gouda Cheese Spread

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49
Marieke Gouda Hatch Pepper Cheese Spread

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49
Marieke Gouda Honey Clover Cheese Spread

Regular price

$9.49

Sale price

$9.49
Medium Brick (Wunderbar)

Regular price

$8.25

Sale price

$7.99
Medium Swiss

Regular price

$12.49

Sale price

$12.49

Previous page
Page 4 of 7
Next page

Order Ahead for In-Store Pickup!

Place Order Online or Call 1-608-846-4455